This assignment was to read two articles on The Trolley Problems and write a short paper summarizing the two problems and my responses. include in this paper are the respectable approaches using the Kantian theory and the Utilitarian theory. The ending will show the strengths and weaknesses of both(prenominal) approaches and reveal which I would prefer to use and why.
The send-off streetcar problem is about a runaway cable tramway that is on the strain to kill five people. I have the faculty to save either five of those people by changing the agency in which the trolley is traveling by passing playping a switch. In this event, I would have to sacrifice one unsuspicious individual who would be on the course of the new direction the trolley would travel. The second trolley problem is the same trolley with the same situation except instead of changing the course or direction of the trolley I could save all five people if I vigoured an unsuspecting individual hit a bridge and onto the tracks the trolley is traveling on. This would ensure manner of speaking the five but, of course, killing the one individual. My response in the first trolley problem is to flip the switch and save to a greater extent people. In the second trolley problem case I would do nothing. I would not be able to push someone to their death in order to save others.
It seems unsportsmanlike of me to be able to send someone to their death in the first situation but not the second; however, I would feel more to blame in the second case.
If I was to apply Kantian ethics to the trolley problem I would not even consider how I would feel when fashioning the decision. My feeling should never play a part of an ethical decision (Waller, 2011). My actions have to stem from duty (of universal law) to be qualified to be considered example or have moral worth (philosophy.lander.edu, 2011). The Kantian approach would not be to flip the switch or throw another man everyplace the bridge because it would violate the categorical imperative. The categorical imperative can...If you emergency to get a full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper
No comments:
Post a Comment